ÐÇ¿Õ´«Ã½

Politics

    • Federal health spending has outpaced provinces, analysis shows

    Canada's premiers hold a press conference following a meeting on health care in Ottawa on February 7, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick Canada's premiers hold a press conference following a meeting on health care in Ottawa on February 7, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
    Share
    OTTAWA -

    Despite castigation from provincial premiers over lagging federal contributions to health spending, an analysis of 20 years of health funding data shows that federal transfers have mostly outpaced increases to provincial health budgets.

    In 2023, federal health transfers amounted to $47.1 billion, a 212 per cent increase over 2005, when the transfers were $15.1 billion. Total spending by all 10 provinces grew in that time to $221.9 billion up from $86.2 billion, an increase of 158 per cent.

    The Canadian Press, in partnership with Humber College StoryLab, collected data on provincial health budgets and federal health transfers from 2004 to 2023 to track annual spending from the launch of the 2004 federal-provincial health accord under former Liberal prime minister Paul Martin.

    The findings stand in stark contrast to the rhetoric that has punctuated federal and provincial health negotiations over the last several years, as health systems struggled in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic.

    Two years ago, a shortage of health workers led to emergency room closures and extreme backlogs for services across the country and premiers demanded the federal government pay a greater share of the health spending bill.

    Former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson, after a meeting with her fellow provincial leaders at the end of 2022, said health spending used to be split evenly but the federal share had slowly dwindled over time.

    Governments originally envisioned that health-care costs would be divided evenly between Ottawa and provincial governments in 1959, before most provinces even had medicare. But the funding model shifted drastically in the 1970s and has changed again many times since.

    Rather than slowly dropping off over the last two decades as the premiers suggested, the data shows federal transfers actually grew at a slightly faster pace than provincial health spending since the Martin health accord in 2004.

    In 2005-06, federal health transfers grew 39 per cent in one year while provincial health spending grew by six per cent.

    That meant the federal share of total health spending jumped to 20.7 per cent from 17.5 per cent.

    Federal health-care spending was far higher during the COVID-19 pandemic because of specific transfers. Those extra funds stopped flowing in 2022-23, by which time the federal share of total provincial spending had grown just slightly to 21.2 per cent.

    That reality wasn't acknowledged when premiers were clamouring for more federal money after the pandemic, Health Minister Mark Holland said in a recent interview.

    It was also not acknowledged in his recent negotiations with provinces as part of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's proposed $196-billion health deal, which involved signing one-on-one agreements with each province.

    "I understand the position of the provinces -- huge demands on them -- but we have been ensuring that we're providing the dollars that are necessary and required to help them in their health systems," Holland said.

    "Now what we need to do is to begin to transform how our system functions. We need to move from a crisis-based system where we wait until people are really sick and then we deal with it, to being upstream and avoiding illness and being engaged in prevention."

    Ontario Premier Doug Ford declined The Canadian Press's interview request as chair of the Council of the Federation, the official organization of the premiers.

    A written statement said premiers "continue to urge the federal government to provide adequate and sustainable health-care funding," also reiterating their concerns that the agreements have an end date.

    The premiers call that the "funding cliff," fearing they can't plan for long-term stability when federal offers all have expiration dates.

    In February 2023, about 10 days after Trudeau tabled the latest health funding offer, the premiers issued a joint statement to reluctantly accept it.

    "While this first step marks a positive development, the federal approach will clearly not address structural health care funding needs, nor long-term sustainability challenges we face in our health-care systems across the country," they wrote.

    Getting a clear view of who is paying the growing cost of Canada's health care isn't straightforward.

    No government is collecting health spending data on a national scale, and federal contributions are difficult to pin down.

    It's important to know how much each government is contributing so that voters can hold them accountable, said Haizhen Mou, a professor with the University of Saskatchewan's graduate school of public policy.

    "They have certain expectations on the quality and quantity of health care they receive, however, they cannot hold either level of government accountable, because there's no clear division of responsibility," said Mou, who studies health funding and politics.

    "There's no clear, no transparent contribution ratio or expectation for this contribution from either government in the system so far."

    The Canadian Press and Humber College StoryLab combed through decades of provincial public accounts and federal transfers to compile the data manually.

    Territories were not included because health spending records couldn't be verified in some cases. The territories also receive additional support from the federal government to fund necessary travel and accommodations for some patients that can't be treated near their homes.

    The analysis did not account for equalization payments and other federal contributions to provincial general revenues that could ultimately be spent on health.

    Nor did it look at tax points transfers, which the federal government includes when it assesses how much money it is giving the provinces for health care. That dates back to 1977, when the federal government lowered its tax rates for personal and corporate income and the provinces could increase their provincial tax rates and take that revenue instead.

    In 2023, after the latest health funding offer to the premiers was made public, Ottawa said tax point transfers amounted to $25 billion. However, the provinces do not include tax point transfers when discussing the federal share of health-care spending.

    Holland says he's open to finding a way to make information about health spending more available as a way to cut through the political rhetoric.

    "I think anything that provides transparency and allows us to get to talking about the material, consequential things that we have to be doing, as opposed to debating over dollar values, I think is helpful," he said.

    The new health deals call on provinces to improve the collection of national health data, but makes no specific mention of tracking federal and provincial spending.

    The one thing that is clear is that health care spending is growing.

    Per capita, Canada's transfers for health grew six times faster than population growth, amounting to $1,115 per person in 2023, up from $427 per person in 2005. Those figures have not been adjusted for inflation.

    Among the provinces, per capita spending grew at massively different rates, with Newfoundland's budget soaring 19 times faster than its population, while spending in Nova Scotia and Alberta grew less than two times as fast as the population.

    This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 2, 2024.

    IN DEPTH

    Opinion

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: Gusher of Liberal spending won't put out the fire in this dumpster

    A Hail Mary rehash of the greatest hits from the Trudeau government’s three-week travelling pony-show, the 2024 federal budget takes aim at reversing the party’s popularity plunge in the under-40 set, writes political columnist Don Martin. But will it work before the next election?

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: How a beer break may have doomed the carbon tax hike

    When the Liberal government chopped a planned beer excise tax hike to two per cent from 4.5 per cent and froze future increases until after the next election, says political columnist Don Martin, it almost guaranteed a similar carbon tax move in the offing.

    CTVNews.ca ÐÇ¿Õ´«Ã½

    According to police, during a traffic stop officers noticed firearms and ammunition inside the vehicle.

    At the end of a side street in Slave Lake, Alta., Lynn Bowes looks at a grey job-site trailer with boarded-up windows and doors that once operated as her town's only homeless shelter.

    Cher, Anthony Hopkins, Heath Ledger, Alec Baldwin and Tom Hardy are just a few of the celebrities John Cumming met while growing up in his family's military surplus store.

    The controversial plan to turn a desert green

    Ties van der Hoeven's ambitions are nothing if not grand. The Dutch engineer wants to transform a huge stretch of inhospitable desert into green, fertile land teeming with wildlife.

    Canada

    • According to police, during a traffic stop officers noticed firearms and ammunition inside the vehicle.

    • Quebec provincial police (SQ) handed out over $15,000 in a two-day span to a series of drivers who were caught speeding and street racing on highways, including some that were construction zones.

    • Guelph tenants worry they'll have find a new home after recently receiving N-13 notices from their new apartment owner.

    • At the end of a side street in Slave Lake, Alta., Lynn Bowes looks at a grey job-site trailer with boarded-up windows and doors that once operated as her town's only homeless shelter.

    • Three teens were arrested for an armed robbery at a Kitchener jewelry store after witnesses caught and detained the suspects until officers arrived on scene.

    • Cher, Anthony Hopkins, Heath Ledger, Alec Baldwin and Tom Hardy are just a few of the celebrities John Cumming met while growing up in his family's military surplus store.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    • It’s been just over a week since the federal government banned nicotine pouches from being sold anywhere other than a pharmacy.

    • Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    Autos

    • Nearly two-dozen drivers were caught in a speed trap outside a Vancouver elementary school on Thursday – as students were settling back into their daily routines.

    • An Ontario man said he couldn't believe an electric car he bought three years ago for $20,000 would need a new battery at a cost of more than $33,000.

    Local Spotlight

    Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.

    Swimmer Nicholas Bennett and para canoeist Brianna Hennessy have been named Canada's flag-bearers for Sunday's closing ceremonies of the Paralympic Games in Paris.

    Halifax resident Tucker Bottomley started feeling the painful effects of rheumatoid arthritis at the age of 21.

    Roger Barker was looking forward to exchanging a book at one of the Little Free Libraries that had been erected in his neighbourhood, until he found it vandalized.

    You never know what you might find in your doorbell camera footage...

    Brenda Tremblay has been an avid gardener for the last 40 years, but this year’s harvest in Colpitts Settlement, N.B., is a tough nut to crack.

    A group of seniors in Ontario is offering their time and experience as parents struggle to find reliable child care spaces.

    Saskatchewan man Clyde Hall has been collecting and restoring antique farm equipment for five decades. He's now ready to part with his collection.

    An Ottawa man has won the $3.8 million prize in the 'Catch the Ace' draw in Maniwaki, Que. Local radio station CHGA 97.3 has been playing their version of 'Catch the Ace' for nearly a year without a winner.

    • A shopkeeper was attacked as she was leaving work in the Mount Pleasant neighbourhood Saturday night, Vancouver police say.

    • The family of a child who was found unaccompanied at a Dairy Queen in Whistler, B.C., Saturday night has been identified, local Mounties say.

    • Mediated negotiations between the union representing striking HandyDART transit workers in Metro Vancouver and their employer are set to begin today, six days into the stoppage.

    • Toronto police say they have now located a missing 11-year-old girl who was last seen in North York late Saturday afternoon.

    • When Sarah Boulby tells clients going through a divorce or locked in a custody battle that their texts and social media posts might be put under a microscope, she usually gets one of two responses.

    • One driver is in hospital with serious injuries and another is facing charges following a collision on Highway 401 in Mississauga.

    • Cher, Anthony Hopkins, Heath Ledger, Alec Baldwin and Tom Hardy are just a few of the celebrities John Cumming met while growing up in his family's military surplus store.

    • Rob Miyashiro was selected as the NDP candidate in Lethbridge-West Saturday to replace MLA Shannon Phillips.

    • One of three rallies organized by the Alberta Union of Provincial Employees (AUPE) took place at the Foothills Medical Centre on Saturday.

    • WATCH AT 6 P.M.

      WATCH AT 6 P.M.

      With CTV broadcasting NFL football games on Sundays this season, CTV News at Six with Austin Lee will be broadcasting live on our website and the CTV News App.

    • The Bank of Canada has lowered its key interest rate by 25 basis points to 4.25 per cent.

    • A truck driver is facing charges after their company asked the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) to conduct a wellness check on them at a service centre in Mallorytown Friday afternoon, police say.

    • As Quebec politicians continue to point to immigration -- a common justification for the province's ills -- as the main culprit for the province's teacher shortage, education experts say newcomers are not the underlying cause of the widespread teacher shortages.

    • Quebec provincial police (SQ) handed out over $15,000 in a two-day span to a series of drivers who were caught speeding and street racing on highways, including some that were construction zones.

    • Two men were injured in a brawl involving around ten people in downtown Montreal on Saturday night, according to the Montreal police (SPVM).

    • At the end of a side street in Slave Lake, Alta., Lynn Bowes looks at a grey job-site trailer with boarded-up windows and doors that once operated as her town's only homeless shelter.

    • The Edmonton Elks are finding a way to return to respectability in what initially looked like a lost season.

    • Nearly seven weeks since a wildfire forced the evacuation of Jasper National Park and burned nearly a third of the townsite's structures, Parks Canada says the blaze is now officially under control.

    • Three Halifax Regional Municipality councillors will not be running for reelection in October.

    • The RCMP Antigonish County District say they have charged a 27-year-old man with multiple driving offences after he failed to stop for police on several occasions.

    • A 37-year-old woman from Bathurst, N.B., has died following a two-vehicle collision in Allardville, N.B.

    • Those living in the city’s Waverley area will have a chance to shoot some hoops at a new outdoor basketball court at Bridgewater Park.

    • Grand Chief Cathy Merrick of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs will lie in state at the provincial legislature following her sudden death.

    • The Winnipeg Blue Bombers defeated the Saskatchewan Roughriders 26-21 on Saturday, marking the team's fifth-straight victory and fifth Banjo Bowl win in a row.

    • An investigation is underway after a fire broke out at a residential apartment building in Regina’s Rosemont-Mount Royal neighbourhood.

    • The North Central Community Association has partnered with the Rainbow Youth Centre on a new mural in the heart of North Central.

    • A local elder was honoured at Westminster United Church on Saturday by having a medicine wheel dedicated to her.

    • According to police, during a traffic stop officers noticed firearms and ammunition inside the vehicle.

    • Faye Dzikewich continues to fight for answers for her 36-year-old son, who died after spending the night in an Ontario Provincial Police cell in Rockwood, Ont.

    • One person was airlifted to hospital by Air Ornge with life-threatening injuries. Two other people were transported by ambulance with serious but non-life-threatening injuries.

    • In the wake of the tragic incident of setting a student on fire at Evan Hardy Collegiate, Saskatoon Public Schools announced that it is providing counselling services to students and staff affected by the event.

    • The victory moved the Bombers into top spot in the CFL's West Division, while the Roughriders remain in third after failing to win for a seventh straight outing.

    • Broadway avenue was alive with the bustle of Saskatoon residents enjoying their weekend. The street was closed off and turned into a pedestrian walkway for a massive street festival that saw thousands of participants.

    • According to police, during a traffic stop officers noticed firearms and ammunition inside the vehicle.

    • Ontario is reporting the first human case of rabies contracted in the province in more than half a century.

    • Owen Sound police are searching for witnesses after a pedestrian was dragged by a vehicle.

    • The London Police Service is searching for a missing 16-year-old.

    • video

      video

      The annual London and District Walk for Parkinson’s brought in $61,000 on Saturday, supporting those in the community with the disease.

    • Fire crews responded to a fire at Berczy Park in Barrie early Sunday morning, where a group of people using the area as a campground received a three-day eviction notice from the City earlier this week.

    • A Saturday evening fire in the Town of the Blue Mountains caused significant damage at a residential chalet near the ski resort.

    • Three vehicles were involved in a crash on Bayshore Drive near Frank Street in Midland on Saturday.

    • One person has died following a collision Saturday night.

    • The Windsor police said Pillette Road is closed from Grand Marais to Plymouth due to an active investigation.

    • The Essex County OPP have laid charges following a single vehicle collision and car fire.

    • Swimmer Nicholas Bennett and para canoeist Brianna Hennessy have been named Canada's flag-bearers for Sunday's closing ceremonies of the Paralympic Games in Paris.

    • A shopkeeper was attacked as she was leaving work in the Mount Pleasant neighbourhood Saturday night, Vancouver police say.

    • Mounties in northwestern B.C. say they have arrested the suspect in a fatal shooting almost exactly a year after it occurred.

    • A man has now been charged for his alleged role in a hit-and-run that killed a teenager in Kelowna, B.C., last fall.

    • Mounties in Kelowna are appealing to the public for help reuniting a stolen puppy named Lulu with its owner.

    • Rob Miyashiro was selected as the NDP candidate in Lethbridge-West Saturday to replace MLA Shannon Phillips.

    • It’s been just over a week since the federal government banned nicotine pouches from being sold anywhere other than a pharmacy.

    • A more inclusive and welcoming land acknowledgment has been released by the City of Lethbridge.

    • The Robinson Huron Treaty of 1850 Gathering 2024 will take place in Greater Sudbury at the Anderson Farm Museum on Sept. 8 and 9.

    • A pasta shortage in Sault Ste. Marie is almost never the case, but for one local food bank, the common carb was a rare sight just a few weeks ago.

    • A 41-year-old resident of the Sault is accused of posing as a teacher from Wasaga Beach and threatening a child from a nearby community into sending intimate images of themselves.

    N.L.

    Stay Connected
    Follow CTV News